That's a pretty terrible analogy.

What I have in Pocket is more than a bunch of bookmarks, it's a local archive of everything I've added. I can read it in a nice flowing text format and benefit from limited search functionality. I can reference anything in there anytime whether I have connectivity or not, whether the source page still exists or not.

>Let's face it, if you aren't reading it in the first week, you probably never will - except maybe that one article you plan on reading when you're travelling a few weeks from now.

Stop projecting your habits and use case onto everyone else.

Might not be true for you, but i am sure its pretty common behaviour. I have given up on read-later apps because stuff just kept piling up. Noawadays i just leave the tabs open until i have read something of interest and if i figure that it isnt interesting enough after a few days i just close the tab and forget about it. That way i am managing my to-read list on a daily basis and it doesnt go back later than a week. With chrome sync its also easy to grab the open tabs on my other devices and read them there.

That being said things might be different if i had a long communte or had more freetime after work, but in that case i am usually reading a book, if i am reading anything at all. Giving the brain some relaxation time from the constant bombardment of tech "news" is nice as well.

I think you're missing the point and stuck in the use case of these tools as simple bookmarks or reading lists.

I have little reason to remove anything, ever. It's all being stored for free/negligible cost. I can reference it whenever and wherever I like.

>In the case that you need that knowledge again, you just dig it up on google (if you can remember it).

Right, I can search Google's index how ever many billion pages, hoping that what I want still exists online and that I can remember something specific enough about it to filter the specific needle I want out of the world's largest haystack.

Alternatively, I can just search the store described above which holds point in time copies of the relatively tiny subset of things I've actually seen or at least found interesting in the past. I can use utterly generic, half remember descriptions like "database" and get just a few matches rather than the 764,000,000 of Google.

>Might not be true for you, but i am sure its pretty common behaviour.

That's fine, I understand how people might choose to use these service differently than I do.

This tangent started with mtgx claiming an inability to understand why anyone would care about longevity or keep years of data in such tools.

I'm trying to help with that understanding.

I too have hundreds of read articles sitting in my Instapaper's archives, and a few dozens of favorites. I'm more concerned for them than the unread articles.

If Pocket goes away in the blink of an eye, what becomes of your archives & favorites?

Seems like the type of thing to be proactive about it.

Pocket has an API that you could use to sync with another similar service , or roll something of your own. They also have a simple export which provides a list of source URLs for what you've pocketed.

I've set Kippt up to retrieve from Pocket and used to the manual export to load things into historious [1].

As a last resort, on the Android version all the offline assets and pages can be found here [2].

1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5610492 2: com.ideashower.readitlater.pro/files/RIL_offline

That said, moving away from Instapaper was some grunt work but not too hard - I've opened every link in a tab and used hotkeys to add them to my new weapon of choice (Reading List).