Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I for one do not think camera phones are chill, and many enterprises do not allow them in the workplace. I do not allow for people to take my picture or record me without my permission.

As a professional photographer, I have my subjects sign a release before or shortly after I take a picture they’re in. If they refuse to sign, I delete the material.



Interesting. I've never heard of a workplace where you can't bring your iPhone on the premises, but I guess there must be some. You must admit it's rare in the white collar sector.

> I do not allow for people to take my picture or record me without my permission.

I don't see how you have much control over it, at least in public. Maybe you live in a country where preventing others from recording you is a legal privilege.


“Maybe you live in a country where preventing others from recording you is a legal privilege.”

In most countries, you can’t just take pictures of random people without their permission.[1]

“I've never heard of a workplace where you can't bring your iPhone on the premises”

Banks and other financial institutions, airports, R&D facilities, defense sites, governmental institutions, the list goes on.

Not so long a go, I worked at the headquarters of a bank where I could only bring a dumb phone without camera.

[1] Even pro-personal invasion sites are cautious: http://photorights.org/faq/is-it-legal-to-take-photos-of-peo...


> "In most countries, you can’t just take pictures of random people without their permission."

Citation needed, as a fellow photographer. Photographing people in public places, without consent, is entirely legal in almost all developed countries.

Some countries have stricter rules regarding publishing or publicizing these images, but restrictions on photographing people in public spaces without their consent is quit rare in the developed world.

Japan[1] has some of the strictest laws re: photographing random people, and even that is very much liability-based after the fact rather than a ban.

[1] http://tonymcnicol.com/2009/01/26/photography-in-japan-what-...


From the site you linked: "'You can't take my photo without permission'. Oh yes you can, usually." It's fairly clear cut that there's little you can do about it.

And I know for sure that banks don't forbid camera phones at least in general, because my father worked at one and all his people had blackberries. This was years ago, and camera phones have only become more ubiquitous.


“I know for sure that banks don't forbid camera phones at least in general”

I gave examples of settings where camera phones might be forbidden. At most regular branches of banks, they’re probably fine. I worked at the headquarters of a bank that also served as distribution center of most of my nation’s cash bills.


OK, so, it's rare. And you've as much as admitted that there's almost nothing you can do about it in public, so I've accomplished what I wanted to in this discussion.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: