Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is the fundamental question about experience.

You may be "right". What you consider to be "seeing" things in one's head may be not what's happening in that person's mind. What they call "seeing" may be something else.

The best way I can describe it is essentially generating a memory. If I were instructed to picture an apple in my mind, I could imagine a hand holding up an bog standard Red Delicious. I can imagine it free-floating. And it would be much like when I remember what happened yesterday for instance. Of course, we get into whether or not we "see" the memory or not.

So, if you are saying you do not consider yourself to have mental images, what, to your best ability to describe it, do you do when you remember an event?



Personally, I remember "facts" about the event. Like, who was there, when it was, what was said. I don't have mental images of an event.


So it's like an analytical description of the event?

You don't remember sensations about an experience, like touch, smells, etc?


Basically? It's a "sense" or "vibe". "There was a guy begging on the street" is what I remember. Not the actual words or a picture, just the "vibe" of that sentence. Definitely no touches, sounds, smells, or pictures.

My wife, who has a very visual and auditory memory, to the point that she can basically re-watch movies in her head, is still dumbfounded by this fact.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: