Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


> the rest of the world is broke and needs US markets

The rest of the world is disorganised. If India, China, Iran, Russia and the E.U. implemented sanctions on America, not only would our economy crumble but our ability to fight even a single war of attrition would fail.


JumpCrisscoss, love you dawg but "if" is doing a lot of heavy lifting here.


Oh absolutely. I don’t think we’re seeing Behemoth rising [1].

I’m just pointing out that the structural source of American power is our unity across a continent. Nobody else has that hegemony. Our markets are rich because they’re big, and they’re big because they’re unified.

That bigness also reduces the incentives for others to unify, given they can gain our economies of scale through trade and without the pesky reconciliation (or annihilation) unification would require.

I’m not arguing that Eurasian unification is probable. Just that it’s more likely now than it was before, and that’s a real diminishment of American power irrespective of what the accountants say. (I’d also argue that the aforementioned economies enacting a break with America wouldn’t require long-term unification, just a short-term alliance of the power-balancing types that put America and the USSR on the same side of a war.)

[1] https://geopoliticalfutures.com/the-world-ocean-versus-the-c...


All very good points and something to think about. Especially short term vs long term unity.


This is becoming less and less true. Trading with the US is unappealing because it is expensive (tariffs) and fraught with uncertainty. New trade deals are being forged as we speak between countries that were not even considering each other before Trump took office.

Nations realign slowly but there is no question they've all begun pivoting away from the US to various degrees, and they're unlikely to go back any time soon.


India is gaining massively on this. China zeems to be the real winner. Russia cant stop to celebrate this development.

The rest of the world is dealing among themselves, including Argentina who sells to China.


We just cut a $20 billion check to Argentina. So that they could then undercut our soybean sales even further.

Edit: Guess I should add, now that China will not buy our soybeans, we are propping up a different country’s agricultural market, and are quite likely to soon cut a check to farmers who are struggling because of administration decisions.


> Russia cant stop to celebrate this development

China is winning. India is pivoting. Russia is still losing.


Russia doesn't have the demographics to win, and they're throwing what young workers they have into a Ukranian meat grinder. (Or a war-focused economy that's going to leave them uncompetitive in any other industry)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Russia#/media/...

The longer the Russian-Ukranian war drags on, the more likely Russia becomes a third-world resource extraction state on the other side of it.


They make gains now as much as I hate it. Both territorial and in hybrid war by being able to prop up pro russian politicians

But really, Russia could not wish better president for them then Trump.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: