I've played it three times now, start to finish, and I still enjoy Divinity 2 a lot more. Story wise BG3 I think has a slight edge, but combat wise Divinity is just a much better game(imho). Partially this isn't BG3's fault but it's the consequence of relying on D&Ds rules for its combat, but then.....it was their choice to go that way. BG3 but with Divinity's combat system would be my #1 game of all time.