"If you down-vote you ought to be required to provide an explanation"
Here is an idea:
- require downvoters to provide that explanation.
- Use some simple automated method (e.g. run the text typed through a language recognizer, and see whether it thinks it is English) to prevent simple key-banging as a response.
- by default, do not show the explanations, but do show a 'has downvotes' indicator and a 'show downvotes' control (could be a single UI element)
- when showing downvotes to a user, do not show author names.
- allow users to flag downvotes as inappropriate.
- let the powers that be manually check flagged downvotes (hopefully, there aren't many), and take appropriate action against either the downvoter or the flagger, or both.
Here is an idea:
- require downvoters to provide that explanation.
- Use some simple automated method (e.g. run the text typed through a language recognizer, and see whether it thinks it is English) to prevent simple key-banging as a response.
- by default, do not show the explanations, but do show a 'has downvotes' indicator and a 'show downvotes' control (could be a single UI element)
- when showing downvotes to a user, do not show author names.
- allow users to flag downvotes as inappropriate.
- let the powers that be manually check flagged downvotes (hopefully, there aren't many), and take appropriate action against either the downvoter or the flagger, or both.