Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Love the idea! I mainly use YouTube to find interesting music, and this would (will?) make that easier.

The interface seems sketchy though. Sometimes clicking on a song in the results list doesn't do anything. Other times there's a little flash, but it doesn't switch to playing that song. Sometimes it selects the song and the video appears to load, but it doesn't actually start playing. In general, the UI is frustrating because it looks clean and polished, but a gesture has the desired effect only about 75% of the time.

Another issue I found is that sometimes I get what seems to be the wrong video—it's not the song listed, and appears to be completely unrelated. Several times I got a video of somebody narrating a Dickens novel, and once an Asian game show of some kind. It could be wrong metadata on the YouTube side, but it happened often enough that I doubt it.

If you sort out these issues, this could be awesome.



The video not playing properly is an issue with the Youtube Chromeless player I used. I probably messed up the javascript somehow. I'll have it fixed when I implement the new UI.

The wrong video issue is simply the result of the first video result from youtube being wrongly tagged. I can't really do anything about it.


For the wrong video, maybe you can see the likes to dislike ratio? That would filter out lot of bad music too but I guess that's not what you want.

Another way is to use some API to look for the song title and duration, and match it with the duration of youtube video with +-10 seconds.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: