Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

As I said to someone else, look at NYS:

1. There are annual mandatory vehicle inspections. Driving an uninspected vehicle is illegal and you cannot get the inspection certificate for your windshield unless your vehicle passes.

2. The state requires a driving test to get a license (in addition to prelicensing education requirements) and effectively forces everyone to take driver education courses every 3 years by raising insurance rates if they do not.

3. There is a points system for violations. Reach 11 points, and you lose your license. Reaching 11 points is fairly easy to do.

You are saying that improved driver education and vehicle maintenance cannot be done in the U.S., yet NYS does it. You say that people’s licenses cannot be taken away for unsafe driving in the U.S., yet NYS does it. NYS is part of the U.S.



> You are saying that improved driver education and vehicle maintenance cannot be done in the U.S., yet NYS does it.

The problem is, it's only NYS. Not the entirety of the US. And the federal government can't go and mandate it without a constitutional amendment - and the last one has been passed over 30 years ago, so there is no practical chance something as controversial as that could ever become law.

The only way around this would be a repeat of the Minimum Drinking age, similar to what's being discussed for the "SAVE Act" - the federal government effectively forcing states to abide by tying federal highway or other funding to that condition. And that tactic is, let's be real, outright disgusting and trampling on states rights.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: