Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

He had me up until he said "How [can] profits in the financial sector to be consistently higher than profits from [...] agriculture, transport, health care or utilities?"

Those are four very poorly chosen examples which suffer from Baumol's Disease [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baumol%27s_cost_disease

Now whether or not it is true that banks can really be efficient, it's better to compare banks to technology and industrial production that don't suffer from Baumol's disease.



Agreed on the poor choices of examples, though that Wikipedia article is terrible. There's absolutely nothing contrary to classical economics in "cost disease", and Baumol's stuff was more an analysis of the economics of a situation than a sudden discovery of some unforeseen phenomenon.

Articles like the OP link are little more than populist sensationalism. Valid and extremely strong arguments can be made for reform in the banking system, but they aren't made by expressing that banks should be "in service of the people, not the profit." Those are political talking points, and the most offensive is that he compared financial markets to casinos, which is where authors lose all credibility to anyone who understands economics.

Also:

>Price discovery is not a sexy function of markets

Hell yeah price discovery is sexy. If it isn't, what is? The entire stock market exists literally only to set prices as quickly and accurately as possible.


Don't think that one is true of agriculture, at least not since the invention of the tractor, or possibly even the horse drawn plough. As for the others, you may have a point in some areas of medicine in the US, but in transport and utilities I don't think it is a rise in wage costs that are the problem. Also, aren't the rising wage costs in this case largely driven by keeping up professional standing when socialising with people in industries that are behaving unfairly, like some areas of the legal and financial world, who are for fairly obvious reasons able to renumerate their staff to a level far in excess of the work they are actually doing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: