As a matter of fact this would not be a "major undertaking" in Python, unless your definition of the term is majorly loose:

    @dataclass
    class InnerCircle:
        s: str

    @dataclass
    class NPC:
        s: str

    @dataclass
    class Dissenter:
        s: str

    Committer = Union[InnerCircle, NPC, Dissenter]

    class CocReaction(Enum):
        DoNothing = auto()
        ThreeMonthsWithoutHumiliation = auto()
        PublicDefamation = auto()

    def adjudicate(c: Committer) -> CocReaction:
        match c:
            case InnerCircle():
                return CocReaction.DoNothing
            case NPC():
                return CocReaction.ThreeMonthsWithoutHumiliation
            case Dissenter():
                return CocReaction.PublicDefamation

Although in reality you'd likely model Committer as a product of a status and name, and adjudicate as a map of status to reaction, unless there are other strong reasons to make Committer a sum.