Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Wait, but in "Independence Day" they uploaded human-made computer virus into alien computer and it just worked™!


Sure, and that makes perfect sense, since earth tech was based on the alien tech they found in the Roswell crash.

Shame they deleted the scene explaining all that. It's still easy to find though.


> Shame they deleted the scene explaining all that. It's still easy to find though.

Huh! I always thought the logic was that since the aliens used earth satellite systems they had already interfaced with human computer systems and the infection was made via the satellite system, which I believe the main character was knowledgable about.


That doesn't entirely follow, though. Just because you could talk to the alien computers doesn't mean you could execute a program on them. IMO the deleted scene is the only way it can make sense.


Put differently: you can’t run a windows/linux exploit on a Linux/windows machine just because they can both connect to the Internet.


This. But everyones focused on languages lol.

Actually lol, who says the aliens were not running a emulator of our own systems and in their hubris ran it on elevated privs.

ok ok, considering the Aliens allowed their own ship, which was visually compromised AND could have been easily scanned for non-alien life(?)... clearly not a culture of security.


Yah, but worked because the aliens used the humans satelite network against them, to comunicate with their fleet.

Since they where interfacing with out tech, makes sense to use this against them.


That's like saying a C64 virus could work against a Linux box, because a C64 modem was used to control the C64.

And as the virus author, you've never seen Linux, have no idea about anything past the C64, including bioses, CPU structure, APIs, PCI/etc architecture, and all other computing hardware, and?

That's being friendly, because they'd be interfacing with computing systems hundreds, thousands, or millions of years more advanced, written by aliens, which view the universe entirely differently due to different brain structures, with an unknown number or type of senses, with an unknown way those senses work or are perceived, with "code" not necessarily in binary, or using silicon based chips, or even transistors, or.. well, this part never ends.

The premise is immensely absurd.

Of course it is a movie, but this sort of canon puts it into soft scifi, if not fantasy.



If you go with the logic of the deleted scene, it's like asking if an 80s programmer with no knowledge of modern hardware or software could still make a virus that would infect modern systems, which makes it significantly easier to swallow.


NO but a virus made for a linux box that was programed in a c64 could work.


And in War of the Worlds they uploaded a human-compatible virus into aliens and It Just Worked(TM) :P


That was more the aliens being arrogant than humans doing anything.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: