I would love to see some kind of "university achievement test" that you could take at the end of college, or at the end of simply studying on your own.
A test that would actually evaluate real critical reasoning and analysis of the sort that you're "supposed to" develop at university. (Of course, writing such a test well would be extremely difficult, and it would probably have to have a different version tailored for each kind of major.)
But it could serve two purposes: first, it could allow intelligent and driven students to bypass college completely, but still have something that will give them equivalent respect from employers.
But secondly, it could also reveal that many colleges aren't providing educations worth anywhere near what they're charging, and thus either drive prices down, or else force them to raise their standards.
Good idea, but I think some sort of achievement test at the high school level would be even more effective at revealing the quality of preparation students have received for college.
Fortunately we already have tests like this and not surprisingly, they show that students are terribly underprepared for an undergraduate education in nearly every subject.
Clearly an undergraduate education received today is not commensurate with the costs to the student, especially when the student hasn't be rigorously prepared for a collegiate education in high school. But the problem is so much more than the price of tuition.
A test that would actually evaluate real critical reasoning and analysis of the sort that you're "supposed to" develop at university. (Of course, writing such a test well would be extremely difficult, and it would probably have to have a different version tailored for each kind of major.)
But it could serve two purposes: first, it could allow intelligent and driven students to bypass college completely, but still have something that will give them equivalent respect from employers.
But secondly, it could also reveal that many colleges aren't providing educations worth anywhere near what they're charging, and thus either drive prices down, or else force them to raise their standards.