Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Oatmeal is not oatmeal.

There's instant oatmeal. The kind that comes in packets and you just add water. Often has sugar added, often slathered with sugar. Possibly worse than a bowl of corn flakes. Highly processes with most of the starches and cellulose (fibre) reduced to simpler forms and readily and rapidly converted to glucose in the gut. High GI. Almost like candy.

There's quick-cooking AKA minute oatmeal. Gelatinizes in 3 minutes on the stove or the microwave. Still processed so the starches are easily digestible (that was the point when it was invented). Slightly better than instant oatmeal and corn flakes but still mid-level GI and GL.

Finally, there's oat meal. Steel-cut oats are just the seeds of the oat plant lightly crushed into large pieces. Not pre-cooked. Most palatable when cooked overnight. Very high in non-digestible fibre, mostly still complex starches that take considerable time to convert into glucose in your digestive system. Low GI.

It's oat meal that is most associated with glucose and blood pressure control, not so much oatmeal. Rule of thumb: the longer it takes to prepare, the more it takes to digest and the better it is for you if you're concerned about a healthy diet.

But the point is that oatmeal is not oatmeal, and discussing it as if it is is always going to be misleading.



I'm a type 1 diabetic and get to monitor my blood sugar level, and there's just not much difference in between these oatmeal styles when it comes to digesting the carbs.


> Finally, there's oat meal. Steel-cut oats are just the seeds of the oat plant lightly crushed into large pieces.

That's still "oatmeal". "Oat meal" would be a slightly odder way to say oat flour.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: