If you come home from work some day, to find Facebook employees going through your dumpster, are you going to be ok with that?
Probably not, right? You know they want to gather as much data as possible, but you are angry, because you never gave them permission to go through your thrash.
I think thats how some people feel if an application goes through their phonebook, when they didn't give it permission to; the phonebook is not information people consider public; its privileged. Thats where there's a fuss.
That's a reasonable analogy, but I still think the anger should be directed at apple. The way I see it, it's like I told my friend to watch my sandwich for a minute and I come back and someone else is eating it because my friend had handed it to him. I'm going to be mad at my friend; the other guy took advantage of an opportunity to get a free sandwich, which I can hardly blame him for.
Analogy isn't needed at all. Address book uploaded without permission... enough said. To your second point, I agree, Apple should have a setting on the iPhone that denies ANYONE but the owner of the iPhone access to the address book. In addition, each app should be forced to ask for permission to use contacts. The ball is in Apple's court to explain.
Probably not, right? You know they want to gather as much data as possible, but you are angry, because you never gave them permission to go through your thrash.
I think thats how some people feel if an application goes through their phonebook, when they didn't give it permission to; the phonebook is not information people consider public; its privileged. Thats where there's a fuss.