Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

He did it, but still would have a preferred a Dune TV show, especially after the success of GoT, and the streaming wars. The money was there. Characters played by Jason Momoa, Oscar Issac etc only got a little bit of screen time. And all those cool characters would have been amazing to watch over a few seasons.


I totally agree, and hopefully it'll inspire the creation of Dune miniseries and shows, since there's ample precedence there.


https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0142032/ was actually quite good (as was the followup Children of Dune).


Not sure I need to spoiler alert a book that came out over 50 years ago, but Momoa should be back in Part 3.


Ohhh, snap, I wish I'd stopped at spoiler alert..... :(((( haha it's all good. I'd been meaning to read those for a while, but...alas never did.


I doubt there will be a part 3.

I assume Villeneuve got the deal safe for two parts but the numbers don't justify a part 3.

Maybe a TV show could raise more awareness.


Quite the contrary. They didn't green light part 2 until they saw the numbers for part 1, and they were excellent.

That doesn't mean they'll go all the way to God Emperor, but I don't think we know for sure they won't.


Well yeah it was officially green lit in October but I doubt he'd have even started if they hadn't promised him something along the lines. The ending is terrible at this point. How would that look on Master Villeneuve's vita?

I also doubt they'll go for 3 because all following books don't have that kind of action flick / visual extravaganza potential and this is what Villeneuve can do. Instead there is a lot of talk and this is what Villeneuve can't do. It'll still be the same ol' Dune with a lot of chamber play. I doubt he's even seriously interested in that.


I dunno, I think Messiah works as an ending to the trilogy. There's quite a bit of intrigue and action. Nothing gets too weird—Duncan's Ghola is the only new sci-fi addition.

Children takes a sharp turn with the whole possession thing and then Leto's metamorphosis. But Messiah is quite adaptable and is the real ending for many of the same characters as Book 1.


Movie that cost 165 million having a 100 million us box office surely looks like good numbers.


About 1000 times


There is both a Dune TV series and Children of Dune TV series. Both much better than the Villeneuve movie.


Checkout the old syfy channels mini series.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: