Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It is similar to a religion, because if everyone agrees to adopt the same reality, then there's easy communication and a shared background understanding that makes it easy for everyone to work together. Picking a religion is a society-wide coordination problem, and strategies of shaming and in-group/out-group exclusion make sense in this context, where they wouldn't about flavors of ice cream, for example. We see the same thing happening in tech all the time. I don't want to learn a new technology, which means I don't want you to learn it, because I don't want it to become something that engineers are expected to know. And so on.

The point is to understand that "right tool for the job" and "C++ for everything" are religious positions, too. There might even be a dominant religious position, which likes to style itself as just the disinterested rational viewpoint.

The FP folks might be a somewhat more fervent (crazy mathematical) sect, but there's no getting away from religion, though we can call it by other names (fashion, "best practices", ...).



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: