Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Also his website is just affiliate link garbage.

I looked through like 12 categories where I consider myself very familiar with the market for what's available and the product recommendations are poor. At best. Half of the recommendations look like your standard rebadged Alibaba crap peddled on Amazon with all the fake reviews that follow.

I guess the name of the site is a tacit admission that probably the products are not good, but this page is content that's designed to match for certain search terms and not something that's organically good content.

I'm fine with Google ranking this content straight to zero.

Edit: The author is a nice guy and a decent writer. Emotionally, I want to feel for him. But not for content like this.

You can have all of the best intentions and still contribute negative value to the world.



I clicked on the gaming monitor category because it's actually something i've been shopping for.

I was really expecting good content and a single recommendation or two that would replace hours of reading crap reviews, reddit threads, etc. but instead was met with what could be auto-generated list of monitors with scraped descriptions and links

I can really see why this would be flagged as just search front-running for affiliate money


You've stoked my curiosity. Which sub-$200 144Hz monitors are your favorites?


I'm surprised to hear this, not because I think my recommendations are infallible, but because the user return rate is lower than average. Are there any specific products that you think are junk?


He's competing with a huge army of auto-generated spam sites that are in the same business. Best LED strip lights? Good luck getting on the front page of that one. The results are dominated by sites using superficially respectable, popular domains to push the same affiliate spam.


So because he generates functionally-equivalent output, but in a way that passes some vague moral purity test he's the good guy underdog then?


That's not what I'm saying at all. I couldn't care less whether he's the winning spammer or not.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: