Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Privacy issues don't outweigh convenience and familiarity, and are provably not a barrier to massive scale and longevity (see every large social network with 1B+ users). I don't think you appreciate how convenient the single-account, cross server approach is. Discord has made its way across a ton of communities and likely will continue to do so. It held up to scale and scrutiny especially in early covid times.

The problem with basic protocols is they are inherently very slow to develop and iterate, so problems stick around for a long time. UX can vary widely across different clients for the protocol. SMS has had huge longevity and will stick around for a good while longer, but I don't think anyone is arguing that SMS is actually better than the internet based closed systems that exist today.



The thing with discord is, its communities are offspring of other communities. The parent communities are either some subreddit , or some gaming group somewhere, or some forum , or some crypto community etc. The communities centers are elsewhere, not on discord. Most of them can move between chat apps like nomads.


In my experience, there is a huge difference between people active on discord community vs the reddit community in most cases.


But theres still a reddit community. Is there a case where the community went discord only? And are they willing to pay when discord stops being free?


I mean, If there isn't a huge overlap in users of both reddit and discord, then it's an entirely different community on the same topic.

But to answer your question, plenty and not sure if they are willing to pay. Many open source projects now a days start on discord and then eventually add a subreddit. For example, deno.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: