Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Sounds interesting, but could you explain to me why I should use this over something like Azure KeyVault?


They say they worked at Uber and small startups, they mention a ton of alternatives to their product, but never once mentioned Azure KV. And your comment is also the only comment mentioning it. Im not sure what Hacker News has against Microsoft and the Azure offerings, but AKV is one of the best secret managers on the market today. It does 90% of the features Doppler advertises, and the developer experience is awesome, even the deployment experience is great, especially when hosting in App Services (not required!).


There are two immediate reasons. The first is so that you can manage your secrets and env vars in the same way in development as you do in production. Engineers focus a lot on doing this for code, but this hasn't hit the env var space yet. The second is so that all your secrets live in one place. Doppler is your source of truth for secrets in the same way that GitHub is your source of truth for your code. Your developers pull from GitHub, Azure pulls from GitHub during a deployment, etc. This centralization allows for really smooth access controls and auditing.


But the [Secret Manger](https://cloud.google.com/secret-manager) from google is also easy to use and specially firebase environment config is exactly like the demo. Best wishes ...


We don't think of Secret Manager as a competitor, but more of a destination for your secrets. We have integrations with both AWS and GCP Secrets Manager so you can write directly to them from Doppler.

We also can write to AWS Parameter Store.


Hi this is Ruud, founding engineer at Doppler. You can see us as a single source of truth where it is easy to manage your different projects and environments all in 1 place. GCP Secret Manager is great for production, but becomes harder to manage when you want to use it multiple environments with larger teams and in different projects/micro services.


Ick, talk about different products fimoreth! Look at the 4min video. Keyvault could theoretically be a good datastore for the secrets, though.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: