Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

My contention is that the value to be obtained from SAP consulting is $50 for the consulting and $200 for the indemnity against being fired.


I seriously don't know the SAP market at all. It may be the case that there are indie SAP implementors who charge $50/hr. But $50/hr is so low that I don't see how any consulting company could stay in business charging it.

Yes, some consulting firms do charge a premium for their brand†. But all consulting firms charge a premium for shouldering project, scheduling, and employee retention risk on behalf of their clients; those factors alone, before you even factor specialization into the picture, seem likely to be worth more than $50/hr.

I think you may be falling into the same trap Jason Cohen fell into (which would be weird, because, aren't you a consultant?).

On the other hand, note that some big shops, particularly in the big 4, offer huge discounts on consulting rates that they make up on audit works.


_On the other hand, note that some big shops, particularly in the big 4, offer huge discounts on consulting rates that they make up on audit works._

I'd be very surprised to see this in 2011.

Giving discounts to ensure audit work was one of the evils at the core of the Enron collapse and led directly to the _Big 5_ becoming _Big 4_ [1].

Even before Enron, the writing was on the wall. The Big 4 were very cautious about the conflict between highly paid "consulting" and audit work. How can you audit the effectiveness of the financial controls built into someone's SAP deployment, if it was you who implemented them!? This was partially the reason some of the Big 5 spun off their consulting arms [2] [3].

Don't forget, a large chunk of the Big 4 brand is their "independence" and "impartiality". How can you win audit work without those? (OK, doesn't work _exactly_ like that).

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Andersen [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capgemini [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accenture


If you say so. Enron was almost 10 years ago. Discounts were happening last year. The Big 4 make their money from audit and financial work, not IT consulting.


I don't charge $50 an hour :-)


It may be the case that there are indie SAP implementors who charge $50/hr.

LOL.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: