Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Ms Access in a modern form


Isn't this essentially Airtable?


Airtable is only a part of what access can do today. I'm still a fan of airtable for all of the connectivity it provides to other online tools.


1) That's far beyond the scope of a single person's side project

2) What isn't modern about Access? What do you want to change that isn't just removing features?


1) There was a startup a few years back similar to airtable that was acquhired. They had made sizeable inroads to covering the Access footprint. It probably should be a team effort like Airtable though.

It's hard to imagine one person replacing 20+ years of dev effort.

2) Excel and Access prove the need for software in a business and model out use cases.

If Access could render to the web, (similar to lotus notes to domino) that likely would be sufficient. Since most of the access backend is available, maybe that is feasible on some level.


> What isn't modern about Access?

Almost everything.

Access does not have granular security, fault tolerance, auditing, or a couple dozen other features that one would expect in a modern database.


I wouldn't argue if anyone said access wasn't designed to do those things. Microsoft always has the next solution you should move to.

I have seen Access app developers run their access app on top of a MS Sql server to bring that kind of functionality in, though.

Access was less of a database and more "let's work with our data using forms and reports".

It was powerful in the hands of people who understood the data and details they work with day in and day out and let them form solutions for themselves when there was no other way.

In many enterprises access is just there like excel, but custom software is not permitted.


> one would expect in a modern database.

Can’t resist I should thou, access is in my mind an embedded dB that added some features sits closer to SQLite than MySQL. Out of interest why do people choose to use access than SQL express is it the GUI driven development?


That's surprising, considering SQL Server is so advanced.

(My question was genuine, not rhetorical. I don't use Access and had no idea what state it's in.)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: