Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>The word "classified" means it's not intended for public consumption. Do you imagine that governments should not have the ability to keep information secret? How do you think that would work out.

Some information, like the location of and launch codes for nuclear weapons, names of sources in hostile nations, etc absolutely should be secret.

I don't think that because "governments need secrets" we should set up a system where the government can classify something, rendering it unable to be reviewed by the courts, as described in the article I linked to.



> ...names of sources in hostile nations...

Ooohhh, that's quite on point actually. Guess what Assange disclosed plenty of, at great risk to these sources' safety? He is quite far from any sort of genuine journalistic ethics, and I'm not going to complain if he were to be held responsibile for these actions.

(And yes, he used to claim, with no basis in reality whatsoever, that these sources were self-serving for the most part and thus had it coming for them...or something, honestly it's hard to even guess at a coherent argument from his unhinged claims. By now though, I think we all can agree that this was BS. He has garnered an extensive track record of optimizing his "leaks" for shock value while minimizing effort, and disclosing sources' identity does fit the pattern.)


It's worth noting that Wikileaks had requested help from the Pentagon in censoring these names, but the Pentagon refused.

Are you going to hold them accountable, or is this just a convenient stick to smack Assange with?

It's also interesting that, at least so far, no stories have surfaced about the grave consequences for these listed sources. Considering this would have been huge news, one might want to conclude that no smoke means no fire here.


If there had been a way for "ethical journalists" to get access to documented misbehavior of the government, you would have a point.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: