Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not sure I agree that Twitter doesn't have incentive to get rid of the bots. Bots are bad for user experience and contribute to noise that affects the quality of inputs used by journalists, marketing types, etc. to evaluate trends. The article references the number of active users as a critical piece of Twitter's valuation, but Wall Street can't be dumb enough to completely ignore the quality of those users.


I suspect we could brainstorm a long list of things that Twitter should be doing, but isn't.

Since I've never personally tried to solve any of the problems on that imaginary list, it's tough for me to discern between:

1. It's hard

2. It's possible, but has bad side-effects (like censorship)

3. No incentive (ultimately will not help their stock price)


Exactly. At the end of the day, if the problem is not handled, the entire house of cards collapses. At some point, your users abandon your product over the bad UX. At some point before this abandonment, it becomes clear these consumers are looking for more - users are just now starting down that road, I would say. Ball is basically in Twitter's court at this point. Will they adapt? We will see!


If they were serious about getting rid of bots, they'd have to stop lying about the real size of their user base.


The question is whether bots are bad enough for the user experience to make people leave.


Anecdotal, but I left in some part because of the noise created by bots.


I left because there weren't enough bots to bring the average tweet quality up to marginally awful status.


Maybe "journalists, marketing types, etc" shouldn't be using twitter engagement metrics to report public sentiment.


sure, but they do and they're spending money on the platform so


> The article references the number of active users as a critical piece of Twitter's valuation, but Wall Street can't be dumb enough to completely ignore the quality of those users.

Someone on Wall Street is. And as long as there is a sucker to be sold to, the charade will continue.


Every time I try to use Twitter, it feels like they actively try to sell all the noise as signal.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: