Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

A possible solution to some of the problems would be creating (and for official videos, requiring) a chain of trust, enforced by strong crypto, starting at the original recording device and ending at the viewer's display. Some trusted parties would also probably have to vouch for the start of the chain, too.

That basically sounds like the dream world of DRM people, though.



DRM I don't like. But authentication to reporter, recording device, etc would certainly be useful. Plus proof of integrity.

Maybe also cross-linking chains of trust with nearby devices. So devices corroborate each other.


There's an analog hole here ... what's to stop me using a trusted camera/chain/everything to take picture of an 8K screen with a fake image?

(Canon had a "trusted" model as such. It was broken, IIRC by elcomsoft, shortly after release).


Or a Potemkin village.


A camera that shoots 360°, saves coordinates and date, would make it harder.


How could it tell coordinates in either space or time? non-military-grade GPS is spoofable (not really easy yet, but easier by the day) and GPS signal is rarely available inside a building (and sometimes just under an awning or cloudy days, or near skyscrapers - GPS in NYC is horrible; mobile phone GPS are as reliable as they are because they take cell towers and wifi into account).

The important point is " making it harder " - but how hard is hard enough depends on the party in question, and for many important ones, the simple answer is "not hard enough".


The people in a position of power are already in the best position possible to abuse a root of trust like that.

Look at the TLS x509 PKI, its a total complete mess.

This is not a workable solution.


What would definitely work is a blockchain. It would definitely make sense at least for reliably timestamping video recordings.


Only if you also publish your video (or a hash of it) at the same time.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: