Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

To a normal person the title is an argument against taxation. To a socialist it's the proof that taxes ought to be higher.


Anything but, the title literally states that social mobility in Florence is very low, and that capital is more valuable than labor. Bring back the death tax at 90%!


He is calling you a socialist, and implying that you are not normal.


I know and get that, he is an extremist that believes that the landed gentry deserve to rule over the landless serfs. I oppose that destructive policy, as it is a great way to stifle society as a whole and ensure we slide back towards the dark age.


Don't straw man his argument like that. I take it we both consider social mobility good for society. In that frame, defend the estate tax - does it improve social mobility? More than it costs? More efficiently than, say, a Georgist tax, or a basic income?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: