Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>All good programmers are self-taught. No good mathematicians (currently) are. I wonder why this is. Probably boils down to what 'math' is trying to accomplish vs. what 'programming' does.

I think that may be because, in mathematics, it's hard to "follow the thread". For example, while programming, you can take a program (or a technique) and start reading the code, following links on Wikipedia, and you will eventually catch on. That is, you can do a top-down approach without many problems.

However, doing that in mathematics is way harder. It's not easy to take a paper, read it and start searching for concepts you don't know in Wikipedia: they usually require other base concepts and ideas which are not easy to understan. Sometimes those concepts are not even mentioned becauase the author just expects every mathematician in the field to know them, but to the layman it just looks like magic.

So in maths you need a bottom-up approach, and that's hard to do alone. You need someone to tell you what to study next and why, teaching you the applications and the related fields. Doing it alone is way harder than in the university.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: