Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

So your business is workable because it evades taxes? What is this, Russia?


I'm not saying it's Uber's case, but yes, in many cases, some businesses only exist because they evade taxes. That's the reason lobbies exist.


My argument is that we shouldn't allow businesses to exist that flout the law, taxes or otherwise.


So you think we should shut down the oil companies and agriculture companies and all the large banks?


> oil companies

Yes. They've known about their products causing climate change for decades. They should be liquidated.

> agriculture companies

Some, not all.

> and all the large banks

Only the ones that are "too big to fail" or those engaged in illegal activities.


So... who provides the energy that makes our lifestyle possible is this magical world of yours?


I interpreted his "liquidate them" comment to mean basically forcing the companies to break apart and sell everything off, (perhaps seizing all their assets judicially). So, presumably, we'd still have a bunch of oil companies, but they wouldn't be the ones we have now, or nearly as powerful, and their current owners would all be up a creek.


Oh come on. Enough sunlight hits the earth in an hour to power worldwide consumption for a year.

It takes an infinitesimal amount of land if you were going to use solar alone [1]. There is enough wind power potential in the US midwest, from North Dakota to Texas, to power the entire US 4x over [2]. There's enough generation capacity to move 77% of light vehicles in the US over to electric immediately. There's plenty of energy to go around.

Fun fact: The latest budget bill that passed at the end of 2015 had one of the largest subsidies (ITC production tax credit) for solar and wind generation installation ever.

[1] http://cleantechnica.com/files/2015/05/Land-art-AreaRequired...

[2] http://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2015/05/f22/Enabling-... (page 6)


Sounds all good to me, but good luck getting Congress to go along with that.


Jokes on you, taxes in Russia are a flat 10% last I heard.

Edit: why do you think its that small? Yes, because noone paid it when it was larger.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: