Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Voice enabled UIs with some AI capability are the future

I don't know if you are using voice enabled UIs, but from someone who's using public transportation to go to work in the morning, that's not "a little annoying", that's a big no-no. Talking to your watch spooks people around you like crazy, and having to repeat 2 or 3 times (because noise, eh) your command is just uncomfortable. Worst case ever is sending texts with that (as everybody is actively listening to what you are saying).

Sure, these technologies make great marketing material, but apart from the glowing on-stage demos, the actual use case of voice control immediately dies when there's either other people or loud (and fully quiet) environments.



Exactly, and I think mentally controlled UIs will have a greater appeal in some (distant) future for the same reasons.

One interesting aspect of voice vs. tactile that remains overlooked is the amount of energy required for performing something with your phone. It is not at all obvious that voice is less energy consuming for us and thus more convenient. Never heard of any research that would prove it.


> Talking to your watch spooks people around you like crazy

I find there's quite a large disconnect between what people _imagine_ others will find odd, or will 'spook' them, and the reality - which is that the people around you simply do not notice or care.


Sure, you might not want to dictate a text message on the train, but at home its a different kettle of fish. I find voice activation particularly useful in the kitchen - I regularly use it for things like setting a timer or converting units from recipes.


public transport? What kind of peasant are you?

This technology is designed for our self driving Tesla future


I see your sarcasm but Tesla shouldn't have been part of it :)


voice is just an input method. a natural language interface can also support typing or other inputs.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: