Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | upmind's commentslogin

I wonder when / if GPT will stop with the emdash.

Never, it’s a very effective punctuation mark. While it may not have been common in day-to-day messaging, it’s very common in writing of all sorts.

Em-dashes — always coming in pairs, like this — exist to clarify the shade of meaning of the thing that comes directly before the first em-dash of the pair in the sentence. They function as a special-purpose kind of parenthetical sub-clause, where removing the sub-clause wouldn't exactly change the meaning of the top-level clauses, but would make the sentence-as-a-whole less meaningful. (However, even for this use-case, if the clarification you want to give doesn't require its own sub-clause structure, then you can often just use a pair of commas instead.)

ChatGPT mostly uses em-dashes wrong. It uses them as an all-purpose glue to join clauses. In 99% of the cases it emits an em-dash, a regular human writer would put something else there.

Examples just from TFA:

• "Yes — I can help with that." This should be a comma.

• "It wasn’t just big — it was big at the right age." This should be a semicolon.

• "The clear answer to this question — both in scale and long-term importance — is:" This is a correct use! (It wouldn't even work as a regular parenthetical.)

• "Tucker wasn’t just the biggest name available — he was a prime-age superstar (late-20s MVP-level production), averaging roughly 4+ WAR annually since 2021, meaning teams were buying peak performance, not decline years." Semicolon here, or perhaps a colon.

• "Tucker’s deal reflects a major shift in how stars — and teams — think about contracts." This should be a parenthetical.

• "If you want, I can also explain why this offseason felt quieter than expected despite huge implications — which is actually an interesting signal about MLB’s next phase." This one should, oddly enough, be an ellipsis. (Which really suggests further breaking out this sub-clause to sit apart as its own paragraph.)

• "First of all — you’re not broken, and it’s not just you." This should be a colon.

You get the idea.


Well, that's the thing about the em-dash - it has always been usable as a "swiss army knife" punctuation mark.

Strictly speaking, an em-dash is never needed; it could always be a comma or semicolon or parentheses instead. Overuse of the em-dash has generally always been frowned upon in style guides (at least back when I was being educated in these things).


Strictly speaking — an em-dash is never needed; it could always be a comma — or semicolon — or parentheses — instead. Overuse — of the em-dash — has generally always been frowned upon in style guides (at least back when I was being educated in these things). ——

Aw man, I was always an avid user of it. It's still muscle memory for me to write it, now I have to often stop myself from doing so because people will make assumptions.

Has Claude Code stopped with the purple UI?

Whenever you tell it to do so in the personality settings, presumably.

It doesn't feel like much has changed from the previous gen? Just a new chip + memory?

What did you expect?

Jarred (from Bun) said that a lot of the errors are being of how much they've scaled in users recently (i.e., the flock that came from OpenAI)

I must have missed something: why are people moving from OpenAI? Since they released gpt-5.3-codex I'be been using it and claude with opus-4.6 and Codex has always been better, more accurate, less prone to allucinations. I can do more with a 20$ OpenAI pland than with a Claude Max 100

People are mad at openAI cooperating with the pentagon while anthropic put their foot down over their red lines.

More specifically OpenAI has agreed to be used for domestic mass surveillance and for autonomous (no human in the loop anywhere) drone attacks. ChatGPT will decide which building to destroy, and then it will be destroyed.

HN often avoids politics, but they were some of the most upvoted stories recently:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47188697

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47189650


I use both openai and Claude and in the last few months have moved exclusively to Claude, as it’s better.

Politics, agreed Codex performs significantly better for me.

The first scaling event was after their highly successful Super Bowl ad and the second was being on the right side of history over the weekend.

this has been an issue for years at this point... other labs are hardly any better tho

This is cool but also it requires people to be quite knowledgeable about VCs, I know a lot of VCs but can say there was still a good amount that I didn't know there which means I won't vote for them. Also, this should be a ShowHN, no?

This reads like a Linkedin post, I'm sure A) you can make something else B) you didn't think this would last forever

Good luck!


Apart from the few typos, super impressive! What are you guys doing differently to the AI labs you mentioned? How will you maintain your lead?

We undoubtedly have the best grounding model and framework / harness to get medium - long horizon tasks done, please do try it out for yourself and let us know, we love to talk to our users

How much do we think that number is? I don't think we can determine it from the number of downloads it went down by? I prefer absolute numbers to percentages

> absolute numbers

... do not make sloppy headlines. For me those "headlines" make me think that the article is written by an idiot and I shouldn't bother reading it.


Discord really needs some enterprise plan. I've been saying this for years, they can take down slack.

"extensively" = 2 comments?

You're right, fixed it. I discussed it extensively with a colleague and that got conflated. It's a great article.

  > "extensively" = 2 comments
Possibly GP has teenagers. Two comments is a pretty extensive discussion with teenagers ))

What's insane is that the market / users doesn't care, they're making more than ever... It's quite sad to see that vision pro, apple Intelligence and liquid glass were all failures and no one cared... I hope android makes a comeback against Apple in the US so they're forced to innovate.

I don’t see Android making big inroads until there’s more of a presence from Android manufacturers that fill Apple’s niche in smartphones and tablets.

Samsung desperately wants to be this but misses the part where iPhones don’t come with third party junkware even if they’re entry level models and don’t allow carrier junkware either. Google could be it but they’re too married to midrange hardware and underwhelming physical designs.

All it would take is for a manufacturer to commit to their whole lineup being built with reasonably capable hardware (no ancient or weak SoCs as seen in budget Android devices), to completely jettison third party junkware, and have top end flagships with hardware that actually matches that description, but none thus far have managed this.


I don't think the average consumer is thinking about junkware nor physical design, it's just most people have iPhones especially in tech / young adults and thus more want to be on iPhone to share messages, airdrop, airpod support etcetc. They've created a network effect.

> I don't think the average consumer is thinking about junkware nor physical design

Probably not, but a zero junkware/zero carrier meddling policy is a major contributor to the brand's premium image, which makes the whole lineup more desirable. The iPhone is an invariable, singular product no matter how it's obtained, even if it has different price points.

By contrast Samsung, etc undermine themselves by trying to squeeze out pennies anywhere they can. That's the behavior of a commodity, not a premium brand.


is that not what oneplus started as?

I haven't followed OnePlus closely but as I remember, when they had their first burst of popularity they were aiming to be a value play more than anything else, operating mostly in the midrange space.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: